one petal falling
sakura standing against
a tsunami wave—
I was pondering today, as I usually do, about the events of the world. A cup of coffee, pen in hand, and paper in the critical space of potential sits at the perfect distance waiting for my thoughts. As I beseeched the silence — trusting the alchemy of chaos, the misgivings of reality, to manifest truth.
Reality, what is it and whose is it? As a practitioner of poetics, reality is a sandbox — and reality, at its core, is truth. Not to manipulate it, but to hold it up to the light at different angles, to offer grander perspectives of understanding. Which is precisely why truth becomes a target when power decides it belongs to one voice alone.
What concerns me is not any single network or outlet, but something larger and slower; the consolidation of narrative itself. The quiet narrowing of what gets called truth, and who gets to say it. When informative content bends toward power, most people can sense it, even when they can’t name it. What I keep thinking about is what comes after that bend. Not the next outlet to fall. The next target entirely.
If the idea is to keep the narrative of don’t believe your eyes but what we tell you, I think it will be the artists.
More specifically, the poets.
Poets are informers of truth. Whether Emily Dickinson or S. Pearl Sharp, Walt Whitman to Askia Touré—their metaphors spoke as loud, though quieter, than a news anchor.
Here is why: journalism operates on argument. It can be countered, discredited, bought, or simply replaced with a louder voice. But poetry operates on something harder to manage, it works on how people feel about reality before they’ve consciously decided what to think.
It slips past the rational defenses that propaganda is designed to exploit. A well-placed image, a compression of grief into twelve words, can do what a thousand op-eds cannot.
Every serious authoritarian project in modern history has understood this, even when it couldn’t articulate it. The Soviet state arrested Mandelstam for a poem whispered in a room. Nazi book burnings were overwhelmingly poetry and literature, not newspapers. Pinochet’s regime moved against Neruda with a suspicion that outlasted his death. Iran has imprisoned poets with striking consistency across different governing eras. And in America, Amiri Baraka was stripped of his Poet Laureate’ship for writing a poem the institution could not contain.
The pattern is not a coincidence. Power that consolidates narrative is always, eventually, threatened by the people who work in metaphor. Power doesn’t seek the story, it seeks to shape the believer of stories.
Which brings me to Ai Weiwei.
He is not a poet in the traditional sense, but his work functions exactly like poetry in the way it moves on power. When he arranged 9,000 children’s backpacks on a Munich building facade spelling out “She lived happily for seven years in this world,” a response to the Chinese government’s cover-up of school construction failures in the Sichuan earthquake; he wasn’t making an argument. He was making something you could not debate. You could only feel it, or harden yourself against it.
The Chinese government could manage journalists. It could not manage that.
When they detained him in 2011— 81 days, no charges — they revealed something. They had no legal framework sufficient to silence what he was doing, so they simply made him disappear for a while. And even that became testimony. The attempt to erase him generated more attention than almost anything he had made. He said that an artwork that is not political is not interesting. I keep returning to that. Not because I think all art must be propaganda for the right side, but because it names something true about what art is for—it is diagnostic. It names what is present and being ignored. The moment an artist insists on being diagnostic rather than decorative, they become, to any consolidating power, an enemy.
In the American context I am watching, the mechanism would likely begin softly. Not detention. Defunding. Deplatforming. The withdrawal of institutional support. The drying up of grants, residencies, publishing contracts. The velvet before the iron, as someone once said.
But the velvet only works when people have grown comfortable inside it — when the fear of truth becomes less tolerable than the comfort of a managed lie. When that becomes a social phenomenon, the silence doesn’t need enforcement. It enforces itself.
Free speech will be the subject of debate, officially framed as its protection, practically experienced as its erosion. And in that environment, the poet who insists on witness, who refuses the separation between aesthetics and politics that comfortable systems prefer, will find themselves increasingly alone.
That is where I think we are heading. And I think practitioners know it, even if no one is saying it plainly yet or some are too busy planting flowers to see the tsunami.
The question I am sitting with is this: who, right now, in the American moment, is doing the work of refusal? And are we paying attention?
When the wave recedes
collected petals will wave
back to standing tree—

Leave a Reply